Oh, Simon. You brought cranky to a new level last night. After the watching the show, I’m not sure if you liked anyone. 

The top 12 girls had a harder time with the judges on American Idol on Wednesday. Early favorites like Carly got a lashing from Simon. Dark horse Alaina got more praise than she probably expected.

I  have to say my favorite last night was Amanda, the rocker nurse, and my least favorite was Amy, who warbled "Where the Boys Are." Connie Francis is rolling in her grave.

So who is going home tonight? My money is on Luke, Jason Y., Amy and Kady. We’ll see if I’m right.